Counting the Costs – In Missouri, Steel Bridge Saves 25 Percent over Concrete

For those who think that precast bridges are less expensive than steel bridges, think again!

In a cost comparison of two nearly identical short span bridges in Missouri, a bridge engineering consultant found that Steel Bridge 411 in AudrainCounty saved over 25 percent—with an overall 19.3 percent savings in the total cost of the structure—when compared with its precast twin, Concrete Bridge 336. The bridges were both built in 2012, have the same location and topography, with nearly identical roadway length and width, abutments, structural depth and guardrail systems. They even had the same local work crew.

Audrain County - Concrete    Audrain County - Steel

The unique aspect of this report is that a detailed side-by-side comparison of construction square footage costs from the beginning of design to the end of construction was put together, the first time that such an analysis of very similar concrete and steel structures had been conducted. The analysis was conducted by Missouri bridge engineering consultant John Mann, P.E. and Michael G. Barker, P.E., a professor in the College of Engineering and Applied Sciences at the University of Wyoming. All costs were considered, even the cost of using rented cranes.

The study also identified additional potential cost savings that could have saved Audrain County engineers even more, such as the use of simple, easy-to-install Geosynthetically Reinforced Soil (GRS) bridge abutments to handle lighter loads; elastomeric bearings; weathering or galvanized steel; accelerated bridge construction; and the free web-based steel bridge design tool eSPAN140.

What is the significance of this report for cost-conscious, time-constricted county engineers? Some prefer working with precast bridges because they think it saves money. But with this new information, plus the ability to design a short span steel bridge for free with the interactive design tool eSPAN140, steel becomes the better buy.

To read the full case study, click here.

About Rich Tavoletti

Rich Tavoletti is Director of the Short Span Steel Bridge Alliance. He is also Director of the Container Market program for the Steel Market Development Institute, a business unit of the American Iron and Steel Institute, and Executive Director of the Canned Food Alliance. Rich has extensive experience in marketing and communications. He was marketing manager at the Steel Recycling Institute. He earned a Bachelor of Science degree in marketing from Indiana University of Pennsylvania. He can be reached at rtavoletti@steel.org.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s